Objective: To develop critical analysis skills by comparing and contrasting the short stories “A&P” by John Updike and “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates. Instructions

by


Objective:

To develop critical analysis skills by comparing and contrasting the short stories “A&P” by John Updike and “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates.

Instructions:

Step 1: Read Both Stories:

Begin by reading both “A&P” by John Updike and “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates. Pay close attention to the characters, settings, plot developments, and narrative styles in each story.

Step 2: Identify Key Elements:

  • Create a two-column table or chart on a sheet of paper or a digital document.
  • In the left column, list key elements such as characters, settings, themes, and plot points for “A&P.”
  • In the right column, list the corresponding elements for “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been.”

Step 3: Compare and Contrast:

  • Using the table or chart you created, compare and contrast the key elements of both stories. Consider questions like:
    • How do the main characters in each story differ or resemble each other?
    • Are there similarities or differences in the settings or time periods in which the stories take place?
    • What themes or messages are conveyed in both stories, and how do they compare?
    • Are there any significant plot developments or events that stand out in each story?

Step 4: Analyze Author’s Techniques:

  • Reflect on the narrative techniques employed by John Updike and Joyce Carol Oates in their respective stories.
  • Consider elements such as point of view, tone, symbolism, and character development. How do these techniques contribute to the overall impact of each story?

Step 5: Formulate Your Analysis:

  • Write a brief analysis (approximately one paragraph) that summarizes your findings from the comparison and contrast. Highlight the similarities and differences you identified, and provide insights into how the authors use different techniques to convey their messages.

Step 6: Reflection:

  • In a separate paragraph, reflect on the significance of comparing these two stories. What did you learn from this exercise? How does it enhance your understanding of literary analysis and storytelling?

Submission:

  • Submit your comparison chart and analysis.