Read Paper and fill the critique sheet
Link for the Critique sheet format: https://www.mediafire.com/file/g2ael2mm6qruszv/Critique_Sheet_-_AVIA_491.docx/file
Link for the paper: https://www.mediafire.com/file/yuhzdx8vom3i4zn/Runway_Incursions_-_How_to_Mitigate_Accidents_Draft_2.docx/file
Things to Look For: Conducting Peer Critique for Paper
During this process you are encouraged to converse with your partner. Please put all your comments on enclosed comment sheet. This is what you will turn in for your grade.
1. Ensure all sections of the Research Paper are included.
Abstract
Introduction (Does not have to be called “Introduction”, but there needs to be separate section that serves as an introduction)
Background (Does not have to be called “Background”, but there needs to be separate section that serves as a Background)
Hypothesis (Proposals Only)
Methods (Proposals Only)
Conclusions (Lit Reviews Only)
References
2. Check
the Paper for Flow – Does the paper makes sense to you?
Does the paper have the appropriate headings and subheadings? Does the flow make sense? (Does the information presented seem random or does it make sense to you?)
Does the writer explain or define complex terms and concepts?
3. Checka. Did the writer proofread his/her paper?
Does the writer substantiate definitive statements with a citation?
Check to see if the Conclusion section is written based on information found from the research and not just random thoughts outside of the research done by the writer.
Does the writer use the language of research?
APA Issues (Use Slide Deck as a checklist from the Writing Lab Enclosed)
Check for Title Page Errors
Check for obvious In-text citation errors
Check for Headings and Subheadings
Check References: Look for obvious errors (don’t need to check each item in the reference).
Ensure double spaced between lines and references (no more than double space…no additional spaces between references)
Check for presence of hanging idents
Check that references are in alphabetically order
