| Project Leadership Philosophy Rubric (200 points total) | |||||
| Criteria |
Expert
|
Proficient
|
Competent
|
Novice
|
|
|
Value and mission identified |
Leadership philosophy clearly articulates personal values and mission that are connected to specific project environments.
36-40 points |
Leadership philosophy includes personal values and mission, but the values and mission are not closely connected to specific project environments.
30-35 points |
Leadership philosophy includes personal values and mission, but they are too vague and not connected to any specific project environment.
20-29 points |
No mention of personal leadership values or mission.
0-19 points |
|
|
Explanation of methodologies |
Leadership philosophy provides substantial supporting specifics or explanations necessary to clarify the leadership methodologies.
36-40 points |
Leadership philosophy provides some supporting specifics or explanations necessary to clarify the leadership methodologies.
30-35 points |
Leadership philosophy provides only a few supporting specifics or explanations necessary to clarify the leadership methodologies.
20-29 points |
|
|
| Creativity of the philosophy | Leadership philosophy reflects best practices in project management and is creative, thoughtful, and insightful.
36-40 points
|
Leadership philosophy reflects working practices in project management, but may not be creative or thoughtful.
30-35 points |
Leadership philosophy reflects practices in project management, but some practices might not work for the project environment described by the student.
20-29 points |
Leadership philosophy does not provide any working practices feasible for the project environment described by the student.
0-19 points |
|
| Growth mindset | Leadership philosophy demonstrates depth of reflection on personal attitudes, strengths, areas of improvement, motivations and desires.
36-40 points |
Leadership philosophy demonstrates some reflection on personal attitudes, strengths, areas or improvement, motivations and desires.
30-35 points |
Leadership philosophy demonstrates limited reflection on personal attitudes, strengths, areas or improvement, motivations and desires.
20-29 points |
Leadership philosophy demonstrates no reflection on personal attitudes, strengths, areas or improvement, motivations and desires.
0-19 points |
|
| Quality of writing | Leadership philosophy is well-organized, coherent, and well proofread.
28-30 points |
Leadership philosophy is focused and well-organized, but the paper needs some proofreading.
24-27 points |
Leadership philosophy lacks focus or transition; Needs significant proofreading.
16-23 points |
Leadership philosophy is not focused and needs major revision.
0-15 points |
|
| Word Limit | 450-500 words
10 points |
400-449 words
8-9 points |
300-399 words
5-7 points |
Less than 300 words
0-4 points |
|
